Home » Buying Guide » Best Anti-Itch Cream for Tattoos 2022 – Relieve Itchy Tattoo

Best Anti-Itch Cream for Tattoos 2022 – Relieve Itchy Tattoo

Disclosure: We are reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

When you doubt what can soothe your itchy new tattoo, you need an anti-itch cream for tattoos that will relieve the annoying itchiness instantly. Refer to our suggestions for fast and efficient skin healing.

Itching is always an annoying thing, especially when you are not allowed to scratch that skin area. And, the itching part is a common one when it comes to healing tattoos.

The skin was traumatized with needles and under a lot of pain, so normally, when the tattoo heals the skin will feel itchy as the healing comes to an end. The obvious solution for this issue would be the best numbing cream for tattoos you can find, but the choice is not so easy when you have a load of options.

There are different skin types, various brands, and ingredients, and skincare of this kind is not taken lightly. So, today, we will assist you in choosing the best anti-itch cream for tattoos to relieve an itchy tattoo in no time.

Best overall

Ora’s

Anti-Itch Cream
  • No harsh chemicals
  • Promotes fast healing
  • Eco-friendly

Premium Pick

Hustle Butter

Tattoo Anti-Itch Cream
  • Softens the skin a lot
  • Balmy formula
  • Vegan ingredients

Budget Pick

Mad Rabbit

Tattoo Balm
  • Deep hydration
  • Good for sensitive skin
  • Vegan ingredients

Below are the 10 best anti-itch creams for tattoos that will without a doubt relieve the itchy tattoo, and contribute to other benefits for a newly tattooed skin as well. You will make your pick easily with our pros and cons, all in detail in the sections below.

Why do you need an anti-itch cream for tattoos?

The anti-itch cream for tattoos is beneficial and even obligatory in many ways. First, it relieves the itching that is normal for tattooed skin, and you won’t risk scratching and picking at the skin after applying this cream. Another benefit is reducing the pain sensation overall; these creams soothe the skin and reduce any redness or inflammation-like symptoms.

All in all, it all contributes to you not touching the healing tattoo, and the skin feeling not irritated.

The anti-itch cream for tattoos is for all people who have recently done a tattoo or plan to do one very soon. It is a good idea to have this beforehand before the tattooing, and start the healing skincare timely. These creams can be used even without new tattoos, but there would be no point that much unless for this specific purpose.

True, some of the ones we mention can be used for other purposes (like bug bites, cuts, etc.), but the primary goal is healing the skin layer that would (should) peel off after a needle trauma.

The Best Anti-Itch Cream for Tattoos in 2022

anti-itch cream for tattoos

1. Tattoo Salve Ora’s Amazing Herbal Store

Best Overall

Tattoo Salve

Tattoo Salve Ora’s Amazing Herbal Store

If you like a small business lovingly-made anti-itch cream for tattoos, this could be your pick. It is all-natural and herby (if that’s your favorite) and you’ll ensure skin health with the absence of harsh chemicals here.

The first anti-itch cream is the best overall pick, a salve formula from the Ora’s Amazing Herbal Store. This salve is a formula blend in between salve, ointment, balm, and lotion consistency-wise. There are no parabens, artificial harsh chemicals, wheat, gluten, colors, or lanolin, but it has natural oils that promote skin healing.

There are also many good skin-friendly herbs, all carefully picked and infused in the formula. The manufacturing process behind this brand is a caring, small family business that works in eco-friendly ways.  

Product dimensions are 2.25 x 1.75 x 1.75 inches, with a total weight of 0.96 ounces.

Pros

  • Salve formula with perfect consistency
  • Promotes fast healing
  • No harsh chemicals
  • Herbs for skin healing
  • Eco-friendly

Cons

  • Some of the herbs might be irritating for extremely sensitive skin prone to breakouts or similar

2. Hustle Butter Deluxe Tattoo Aftercare Tattoo Balm

Premium Pick

Hustle Butter Tattoo Aftercare

Hustle Butter Deluxe

This balm for relieving itchy tattoos is incredible because it will make you feel like your skincare is top-notch, all thanks to the gorgeous scents! No chemicals, just butter essences, and oils to make your tattoo heal and soften fast.

As number 2 we have the premium pick, an amazing balm formula from the Hustle Butter Deluxe brand store. This butter is more of a balmy formula, not too thick or too runny. It softens the skin unbelievably well, and it can be used before, during, and after the tattooing.

If used during the session, the stencil will not be erased even a bit, and after the session, it reduces redness, bleeding, swelling, pain, and heals the skin faster. All ingredients are vegan and mixed with natural oils and kinds of ‘butter’ – without parabens. Some of the ingredients are delicious-smelling, like mango, shea, aloe, coconut, rice bran, green tea, rosemary oleoresin, mint, and papaya. 

Product dimensions are 2.1 x 2.3 x 2.4 inches, with a total weight of 5 ounces.

Pros

  • Balmy formula
  • Softens the skin a lot
  • Before, during, and after the tattooing
  • Not erasing stencils
  • Reducing redness and pain
  • Vegan ingredients
  • Gorgeous scent / natural extracts

Cons

  • For extremely dry skin, apply more amount of it since it absorbs fast
  • Consistency is a bit grainy; warm it in your hands before applying

3. Mad Rabbit Tattoo Balm & Aftercare Cream

Budget Pick

Mad Rabbit Tattoo Enhance Balm

Mad Rabbit Tattoo Enhance Balm

Give your skin a boost of natural ingredients to heal it – this anti-itch cream for tattoos is chemical-free, but loaded with vegan ingredients. Don’t worry if your skin is sensitive, this formula will only soften and pamper it.

At number 3, we have a budget pick, the balm-cream blend formula by the brand Mad Rabbit store. This creamy formula is also resembling a deep, hydrating lotion that not just heals the skin, but also keeps the colors vibrant and enhanced. It softens and heals the tattoo, and for old tattoos, it can even revive their pigment intensity!

The ingredients are natural and organic, healthy for the skin, and vegan too. No sulfates or parabens though, just healing ingredients in the mix that are suitable even for very sensitive skin. 

Product dimensions are 2.48 x 2.32 x 1.34 inches, with a total weight of 2.4 ounces.

Pros

  • Deep hydration
  • Creamy perfect formula consistency
  • Old pigments are revived
  • No harsh chemicals; parabens, sulfates
  • Vegan and natural ingredients
  • Good for sensitive skin too

Cons

  • The scent is a bit strong for most
  • Consistency is a bit thick, so it needs warming between the palms before applying it

4. New Numbskin Numbing Cream

New Numbskin Numbing Cream

New Numbskin Numbing Cream

This anti-itch cream for tattoos is your perfect pick if you need lidocaine to act fast and efficiently, and if you are pro-vegan ingredients too. You won’t use this just for tattooing (during and after), but also if you want to prepare for painful laser hair removal!

The fourth suggestion we have for you is the Numbskin numbing cream from the Numbskin store brand. This cream is very potent and powerful in its actions because it contains 5% Lidocaine which is a very strong anesthetic when applied topically. By very strong we mean it will stop the itching, and along with that the overall unpleasant sensation you feel when the skin tightens during healing.

Another benefit of this cream is the pain relief and also the general pleasantness and relaxation it offers for the skin. It is perfect for tattooing, and as aftercare too. You can also use it for other purposes, like hair removal with a laser or similar. The effect lasts for about an astonishing 4 hours! The ingredients are all organic and vegan as well. 

Product dimensions are 5.94 x 1.61 x 1.14 inches, with a total weight of 1.13 ounces.

Pros

  • Lidocaine
  • Stops itching, pain, unpleasantness
  • For during and after tattooing
  • For hair removal methods too
  • Organic and vegan ingredients

Cons

  • Extremely sensitive skin could show some minor redness to this
  • Reapplying could be needed for those too sensitive to the extreme pain

5. Ebanel 5% Lidocaine Topical Numbing Cream

Ebanel Lidocaine Topical Numbing Cream

Ebanel Numbing Cream

Are you tired of the itching and the pain at the same time? There is a way to reduce the itching and prevent pain and skin discomfort because this anti-itch cream works on the pain sensitivity as well. Two in one!

At number 5 we mention something a bit different than the creams so far. This anti-itch cream is not just that, but it is anti-pain as well! The formula has the powerful anesthetic Lidocaine 5% that numbs any unpleasantness on the skin, thus preventing the sensation of swelling, pain, raised skin, and so on. This formula is a cream and it will relieve the itchy tattoo instantly!

It also contains good ingredients like vitamin E, aloe, allantoin, and lecithin. The effect of the cream starts in 5 minutes, and it can last up to an hour. The skin will be supple, soft, hydrated, and calm. And, there is no scent, so it works for everyone’s taste. It is not messy, water-based, and easily absorbed. Fear, not allergies, this is hypoallergenic as well.

Product dimensions are 2.3 x 1.7 x 1.5 inches, with a total weight of 1.9 ounces.

Pros

  • Anti-pain with lidocaine 5%
  • Skin-friendly healing ingredients (aloe, vitamin E, and more)
  • Fast-acting, and long-lasting
  • Unscented
  • Deep hydration
  • Water-based
  • Hypoallergenic

Cons

  • Spread it evenly and well, to avoid a sticky feeling in some spots
  • The effect may start a bit later for some people (within 30 minutes tops)

6. Tattoo Care Ointment Black Rose

Tattoo Care Black Rose

Tattoo Care Ointment Black Rose

This anti-itch cream for tattoos is amazing in all senses – not erasing underwater, fast-absorbing, it soothes your skin with the aloe extract, and overall will help you heal the tattoo much faster than usual. Practical to use in every aspect!

The sixth anti-itch cream is from the brand Tattoo Care. Here we have an ointment formula that is similar to a cream consistency, and a balm too. It will brighten the skin, and at the same time preserve the freshness of the pigments. For old tattoos, it revives the old ink, and overall makes the skin look nourished, soft, and rejuvenated in every sense of the tattoos!

The healing is fast, and all thanks to the extract of aloe vera (the scent is aloe vera too). It absorbs fast, and it is water-proof, which is a huge advantage. The cream is not tested on animals and contains no heavy oils that just leave a grease layer. 

Product dimensions are 2.4 x 2.4 x 1.2 inches, with a total weight of 1.28 ounces.

Pros

  • Creamy consistency
  • Brightens the skin
  • Revives ink pigments
  • Nourishes skin
  • Fast healing
  • Aloe vera extract and scent
  • Absorbing fast
  • Water-proof
  • No cruelty

Cons

  • Apply more if you have very dry skin
  • The scent is good but intense

7. Aveeno Maximum Strength Anti-Itch Cream

Aveeno Anti-Itch Cream

Aveeno Anti-Itch Cream

So, you want an anti-itch cream for tattoos, but you don’t want to limit it just for tattoos? It would be great to use one cream for other urgent skin needs too! And this cream is exactly that, whether it is bug bites, or allergies, or tattoo itching too, it is multi-purpose.

From the brand Aveeno we have this amazing anti-itch cream that contains some powerful ingredients that will amaze you instantly upon the first use! This cream has 1% hydrocortisone that relieves the skin pain and irritation, and also has some oat essence, for soothing and calming together with the triple oat essence.

Other ingredients are aloe and vitamin E to remove redness, itchiness, burning feeling, and even relieve other issues like eczema and psoriasis. This cream will be multi-purpose once you find a place for it on the shelves – for bug bites, unknown irritations, reactions to oak or poison ivy, and similar plants and herbs too. 

Product dimensions are 6.69 x 5.83 x 1.65 inches, with a total weight of 1 ounce.

Pros

  • Hydrocortisone
  • Oat and oat essence
  • Vitamin E
  • Aloe
  • For other skin issues too (eczema, psoriasis)
  • For bug bites and allergies

Cons

  • The label states 2 pieces, but often it arrives 1; ensure proper amount with seller and shipping representatives before the ordering

8. Americaine Hospital Formula Spray

Topical Anesthetic Spray

Americaine Hospital Formula Spray

If only there was a magical way to apply anti-itch cream without the messiness. But, there is, and it is just a spray, nothing more! Simple, clean, tidy + you will prevent the annoying pain with the Benzocaine in this formula.

At number 8 we have another specific and different-than-the-others anti-itch cream for tattoos. This is a spray formula that helps not just with the itchiness, but with the pain sensitivity too. It contains the potent Benzocaine 20% which is an anesthetic relieving pain and inflammation among other things. At the same time, you will protect the skin from potential redness and pain, and also heal it. The best part is that this is not messy, and with one or two sprays over the tattoo, you are done!

Product dimensions are 1.44 x 1.44 x 5.63 inches, with a total weight of 3.04 ounces.

Pros

  • Spray formula (easy and not messy to use)
  • Relieves itchiness
  • Relieves pain and redness
  • Benzocaine 20%
  • For other purposes too (bug bites, cuts, etc.)

Cons

  • For very irritated or open-sore skin avoid the spray directly, to avoid a stinging and burning sensation

9. H2Ocean Nothing Tattoo Glide and Soothing

H2Ocean Nothing Pain Relieving Foam

H2Ocean Nothing Tattoo Glide and Soothing

Heal your tattoo, remove the itchy feeling, and also prevent pain and discomfort with this formula enriched with Lidocaine 4%. Notice the effect taking place very fast, and let your skin finally rest and feel soothed with this perfectly adjusted water-grease ratio formula.

The number 9 pick is the anti-itch cream for tattoos from the brand H2Ocean Store. This cream has an interesting consistency; a mix of balm, cream, and ‘glide’. It is easy to apply and spread, not messy, but not very fast-drying either. The formula also has the powerful Lidocaine 4%, so at the same time, you prevent the pain and irritation that is usually felt in the healing stages.

The effect starts relatively fast, so of course, this is perfect for the tattoo session as well. It is a practical, round package, great to carry with you easily anywhere too. 

Product dimensions are 4.06 x 4.06 x 2.8 inches, with a total weight of 10.55 ounces.

Pros

  • Balmy glide cream consistency
  • Not greasy, not drying
  • Fast effect
  • Lasting effect
  • Lidocaine 4%
  • Great for during the tattooing

Cons

  • If you are too sensitive to pain, use more amount of this
  • The container is not filled up during the manufacturing process

10. Vanicream Anti-itch Cream

Vanicream Anti-itch Cream

Vanicream Anti-itch Cream

If you dislike perfumed or greasy formulas, pick this anti-itch cream for tattoos. Light, scentless, and good for even the most sensitive skin. You will get a safe and medically approved formula to relieve your tattooed skin in need of extreme care and healing.

The tenth roundup of this list is the Vanicream brand store with a potent cream to relieve the itchiness and help the good healing of your tattoo. This cream also has 1% hydrocortisone with maximum strength combined with the other ingredients. The formula is light when it comes to overall scent or consistency – perfect if you dislike heavily fragranced concoctions. There is no gluten or chemical colors, no lanolin, parabens to aggravate sensitive skin, and overall the formula is a great fit for those prone to breakouts or irritations.

Another unique perk is that this cream does not cause blackheads that clog the pores; it is non-comedogenic, and this means if you get a face tattoo, use it on the face too! Rest assured of the safety, dermatologists approved this cream.

Product dimensions are 1.75 x 1.75 x 5.5 inches, with a total weight of 2.88 ounces.

Pros

  • Hydrocortisone to relieve the skin
  • Light formula
  • No scent
  • No harsh chemicals
  • For sensitive skin
  • Non-comedogenic
  • Approved by dermatologists

Cons

  • Not intended or too effective for dermatology-related skin issues (like eczema)
  • A bit slow to absorb

How we picked and tested anti-itch creams for tattoos

These next features are all either present in the anti-itch creams we reviewed, or partially (majority of them) are found in one product:

  • Good consistency
  • No harsh chemicals
  • Eco-friendly
  • Vegan
  • Deep hydration
  • Good scent
  • Reviving old pigments
  • Good for sensitive or dry skin
  • Anesthetic included in the formula
  • Water-based
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Fast absorbing
  • Waterproof
  • Not messy (application/formula)
  • Multiusage (for burns, bug bites)

Anti-itch cream buyer’s guide

apply anti-itch cream

Can I apply the anti-itch cream very often?

These types of creams are intended to be used if you have trouble healing the tattooed skin. This doesn’t mean that you need to avoid them at all costs or overuse them, but if your skin feels too tight, unpleasant, and prone to itchy peeling, in that case, it is recommended to use them.

So, with advice from your tattoo artist, you will probably need to use this every time the skin feels itchy and tight; if healing creams are to be used 3 times per day on average, this anti-itch cream could also be used 3 times, or even more depending on how your skin feels.

What if I forget to apply anti-itch cream?

This is not a bad thing, and not very concerning really. Besides, you won’t just ‘forget’ to use this – your skin will remind you when you feel the urge to scratch it intensely!

If my skin gets irritated, is it normal?

It is normal that in some cases, some people could develop some minor redness, rashes, or irritations from anti-itch creams, and this is not uncommon. But, this happens rarely, and only a small number of people are allergic or intolerant to one or two ingredients in most formulas.

If a skin reaction occurs, just cleanse and rinse the skin, avoid the anti-itch cream for the time being, and continue using a nourishing healing aftercare cream or ointment.

Can I keep on using this anti-itch cream even after the healing, as prevention of some sort?

If you love the formula and how it softens or soothes your skin, sure, it is not a bad thing to continue using these anti-itch formulas. Just ensure that all ingredients are ok for long-term usage, and you are all set. Keep in mind that such formulas are best intended and used for prevention or resolving active skin issues, or possible skin issues. It is good to have such creams handy nearby in your household.

Conclusion

If you haven’t decided by now, or you are on the fence between the best or top ratings, let us remind you and recap it all.

The winner was the best overall, Tattoo Salve Ora’s Amazing Herbal Store anti-itch cream with a velvety consistency and without chemicals. The second place was the premium pick Hustle Butter Deluxe Tattoo Aftercare Tattoo Balm for deep softening, vegan ingredients, and superb scent. And, third place was the budget pick Mad Rabbit Tattoo Balm & Aftercare Cream for healing current and reviving old tattoo pigments with only vegan ingredients for sensitive skin.

Scent or no scent, light or greasier formula, these anti-itch creams for tattoos will not only heal freshly inked skin but also find their other purposes for optimal skin health and prevention of itchiness as well. Choose and use, good luck!

Read also: Top Rated Wireless Tattoo Machines